Should we use a fictional sender name for consistency?
When sending marketing emails from a multi-person department, would you suggest creating a fictional name so that if team members change, the sender is consistent or does this granular consistency not matter as much as I may think?
Consistency matters. Human names, not as much.
Your instinct is correct: Consistency in your sender does matter. That’s how you build trust over time.
But here’s what matters a lot less: That you use a person’s name.
And here’s why: The #1 reason people open an email isn’t because it looks like it came from an individual. It’s because it feels relevant. And they can’t assess if something is relevant if they don’t know who it’s from.
The scenario you’re describing likely falls into one of two buckets.
1️⃣ Shared inbox replies
If multiple people are answering emails, the sender should be the department.
The individual replying can absolutely sign their name in the signature. But the “From” field doesn’t need to rotate every time someone new hits send.
2️⃣ Mass emails from a department
Using a person’s name instead of a department does not automatically make an email feel personal. The real question is this: What is my reader most likely to recognize?
Click on your vote.
A prospective student would recognize:
From: Taylor Clark
vs.
From: Queen’s Admissions
An alum would recognize:
From: Suzanne Ross, Acting Dean
vs.
From: OSU Economics
You after Amazon sent you the wrong thing:From: John S.
vs.
From: Amazon Customer Service
Hopefully you get my point (and at least one of those links made you smile).
Bottom line: Use a sender they know and don’t lie.
Use a person’s name when your audience knows that person. When they don’t, use the department or brand they already recognize.
And definitely don’t invent a fake human just for the sake of consistency. And also, don’t pretend the email came from an individual when it didn’t.
Basically, lying is never good. Readers can sense fake and it will cost you in trust.
This post was originally sent as an email. Subscribe to my newsletter and get the newest questions and answers in your inbox.
